top of page
Writer's pictureItty Bitty Bakers

Inaugural Kids Christmas Cookie Bake Off 2020 + Winners!

Here is recap, as written by Emily Sparacino for the Shelby County Reporter:


During a holiday season that, like the majority of 2020, was different for many families, a local baking school brought a dash of cheer to children through a new event. The first Itty Bitty Bakers Kids Christmas Cookie Bake Off on Dec. 20 saw young bakers compete in three categories: Best Tasting Cookie, Most Festive Cookie and Most Unique Cookie. The contest served as a creative outlet and safe event for the nearly 20 kids who participated.


“Many kids didn’t get to see or visit their extended families this Christmas,” Itty Bitty Bakers Founder Jessica Hamby said. “Most kids were home-bound and stir crazy before Santa arrived. This bake off gave them the chance to work on a creative project and pass the time in a fun, new and safe way. We’d love to keep this going and do it every year and make it a new tradition for them – one that got started in 2020 of all years.”


Contestant Claire Conrad, the Best Tasting Cookie winner, said she wanted to make a cookie that made her think of Christmas, so she found a recipe she liked and then tweaked it. Conrad called her cookies “double hot chocolate peppermint marshmallow cookies.”


“When I brought my cookies to the judges, I felt nervous at first,” she said, “But once I started talking about my cookie I felt excited.”


Contestants presented their cookie creations to the judges on the afternoon of Dec. 20 at Hamby’s home in the Inverness area. Winners in the three categories each received a $25 Itty Bitty Bakers gift card.


“The kids really thought through their recipes, looking them up online and in cookbooks, and then often putting their own creative spin on them,” Hamby said. “Several parents told me the kids really took pride in their entry and worked hard doing it all on their own. Several parents also told me the kids had so much fun doing this event if they didn’t win, they loved being a part of it.”



 

Here are the kids who competed in the bake off. They did an amazing job!


2020 Christmas Cookie Bake Off Winners

🏆Best Tasting Winner and Best All-Around Winner, Claire Conrad, Double Hot Chocolate Peppermint Cookies


🏆Most Festive Winner, Emma Cooley, Christmas Sugar Cookies with Buttercream Frosting


🏆Most Unique Winner, Hailey Duckett, Christmas Tree Wreath Cookies

Runner-Ups:

Emily Grace Jockisch, Best Tasting, Sugar Sprinkle Sandwich Cookies

Abby Harris, Most Festive, Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies

Aubrey Payton, Most Unique, Granny's Special Cookies


 

Need inspiration for what Christmas cookies to bake next year? Take a look at the cookie titles from our contestants! These kids KNOW WHERE IT’S AT!!


•White Chocolate Cherry Shortbread Cookies

•Holiday Cookie Pizza

•Peppermint Meltaways

•Christmas Tree Wreath Cookies

•Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies

•Nutella Shortbread Cookies

•Double Hot Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

•Sugar Cookies with Buttercream

•Grinch Almond Cherry Macarons

•Granny’s Special Cookies

•Peppermint Shortbread

•Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies

•Puzzle Cookies

•Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookies

•Sugar Sprinkle Sandwich Cookies

•Peanut Butter Butterscotch Cookies

•Stocking Sugar Cookies

•Christmas Critter Cookies

•Italian Christmas Cookies

•Snowman Sugar Cookies

•Snowglobe Sugar Cookies

and last but not least…

•“Seed of Light on the Darkest Night” Cookies


 

We couldn't have pulled off this inaugural bake off without the help of our judges!

-Brooklyn Kyzar, owner of Whipped Up and contestant from Season 6 of Food Network’s Kids Baking Championship.

-Our 2020 summer intern and former University of Alabama Crimsonette, Abbey Manasco.

-Local celebrity, storytime teller, and librarian extraordinaire Mrs. Anna Beth from the children's department at the Hoover Public Library.

three ladies judging a cookie bake off
Three judges judging🎶
 

We hope to see everyone back next year! May the kitchen odds be ever in your favor!


Comments


bottom of page